|
Neil Carter, "Party
Politicization of the Environment in Britain," Party
Politics, 12 (November, 2006), 747-767.
First Paragraph:
There is a strange imbalance in the academic study of the
party politics of the environment. While every aspect of
green party development seems to have been scrutinized,
there has been surprisingly little analysis of the impact of
the environment on established political parties,
particularly in countries without an electorally successful
green party, such as Britain.1 Yet the response of
established parties to the environmental issue dimension has
several important implications in any polity.
Figures and Tables:
Figure 1. Environmental protection in party manifestos,
1959-2005
Figure 2. Environmental index in party manifestos,
1959-2005
Table 1. Ranking of environment against other issues in
party manifestos, 1983-2005
Table 1. Ranking of environment against other issues in
party manifestos, 1983-2005
Table 3. Estimated party positions on the environmental
policy dimension
Table 4. Which party has the best policies on protecting the
environment?
Last Paragraph:
To conclude, the main empirical finding of the article,
based on a range of quantitative and qualitative data, is
that the party politicization of the environment in Britain
is limited, but that there has been considerable variation
between the parties. While no party can afford to ignore the
environment, the Conservative and Labour parties have both
pursued a strategy of preference-accommodation,
characterized by a reactive approach to public opinion,
events and issues, but resisting competition over the
environment (although Labour has been consistently 'greener'
than the Conservative Party). The centrist parties adopted a
similar strategy until the early 1990s, since when the
Liberal Democrats have sought to present themselves as the
greenest of the major parties, by consistently making the
environment a core campaigning issue. The party competition
literature has proved particularly helpful in explaining the
different responses of the established parties to the
environment. While new politics predictions have not
materialized, the emergence of the Green Party in
second-order elections in the new multi-level British
polity, particularly if it attracts disillusioned left-wing
voters, could pressure Labour to take the environment more
seriously. The new politics insight that the environmental
issue dimension cuts across the traditional left-right
dimension indicates the importance of ideology in preventing
the two major parties from embracing the issue more
positively. This apparent ideological incompatibility raises
a wider question for further research: is the failure of the
Labour and Conservative parties to embrace environmentalism
a case of British exceptionalism (grounded in the plurality
electoral system), or is it a feature common to all
traditional productivist parties?
|