|
Michael Gallagher, "The Political Impact of Electoral
System Change in Japan and New Zealand: 1996," Party
Politics, 4 (April 1998), 203-228.
First Paragraph:
The impact of the new electoral systems in Japan and New
Zealand can be examined from a number of perspectives.
Change in Japan came at a time of upheaval in the parry
system and it was hoped that it might lead to certain
changes in political style. New Zealand also held its first
election under the new rules in October 1996, after several
decades with its previous system, and since there are
certain similarities between the new systems in Japan and
New Zealand - though there is also a significant difference
- we shall draw a number of comparisons between the two.
Figures and Tables:
Table 1: Japan election results, October 1996
Table 2: New Zealand election results, October 1996
Table 3: Seven (quasi-)electoral systems in Japan and New
Zealand
Table 4: Votes (%) and seats in PR constituencies in Japan,
October 1996
Table 5: Disporportionality in Japanese and New Zealand
Elections, 1993 and 1996
Table 6: Effective Number of parties in Japan and New
Zealand elections, 1993 and 1996
Table 7: Women elected to parliament in Japan and New
Zealand, 1993 and 1996
Table 8: Dual candidacies of members of parliament in Japan
and New Zealand, October 1996
Last Paragraph:
The changes to electoral rules in Japan and New Zealand have
had significant consequences. Power within the parties,
manifesting itself especially in candidate selection, has
been affected, and campaigning styles may alter in future
elections. The impact upon the relationship between votes
and seats was very much in line with what existing research
would have been predicted, though it is not clear whether
this impact was fully foreseen in Japan in particular, where
the electoral system adopted in 1996 was likely to be, and
indeed was, less proportional than the previous SNTV system,
with the LDP predictably reaping the benefit. In New Zealand
the new electoral system, assuming it is retained, will
definitely move the country away from the classic
Westminster-type model of politics and government, and
coalition government is likely to become the norm. In Japan,
the consequences are less clear and there is the possibility
that LDP hegemony will continue.
|